← All articles for grown-ups

When your child is scared, holds on, or refuses

Some children will happily wee on the toilet but hold on, hide, or get upset at the idea of a poo. That pattern has a name, it's common, and it isn't defiance.

It's common, and it isn't defiance

Some children will happily wee on the toilet but hold on, hide, or become distressed at the idea of doing a poo there — a pattern sometimes called stool toileting refusal. It's well studied and it's common, affecting up to around one in five children at some point during toilet training. [1][4] It isn't naughtiness, and it isn't a sign that training has gone wrong — it's usually the body and the emotions getting ahead of what a child feels ready to let go of, in a place that feels exposed and unfamiliar.

It often starts with one uncomfortable poo

Withholding and constipation feed each other: a single hard or painful poo can be enough for a child to start holding on out of fear it will hurt again, and the longer stool sits, the more likely the next one is to be hard and painful too — which reinforces the fear. [2][4] Functional constipation (constipation with no underlying medical cause) is extremely common in young children and it hides behind a lot of behaviour that looks like refusal on the surface. [2]

What tends to help

Research into this specific pattern has tested coaching parents to take the pressure off completely for a period — no requests to produce anything, no discussion of it as a problem — while praising and rewarding calm, voluntary sitting on its own, with no expectation attached. [3] The core idea is to separate sitting, which a child can control and can be praised for immediately, from producing, which they can't control on command and shouldn't be pressured over. Progress is usually staged rather than sudden: sitting on the toilet fully clothed, then with a nappy on over the toilet seat, then without one — each stage worth celebrating on its own, well before a poo is involved.

Why Bo's story is built the way it is

Bo's story exists for this exact pattern. The silly wrong guesses — a sock, a boot, the kitchen sink — give a child something playful to shout "no" at before the real question arrives, rather than asking them to sit still and answer something that might already feel a little frightening. The story ends with a flush every time, because a page needs an ending — but the actual goal for a child going through this is smaller and slower than that, and that's fine.

← Back to all articles